Critique, Analysis and Aesthetics of Texts
Quarterly

Criticism as a Possible Condition in Writing and Speech A Theoretical Reflection on the Presuppositions Covering Whyness and Howness of the Event of Texts

https://doi.org/10.22034/caat.2024.199082
Volume 7, Issue 2 - Serial Number 23
Spring 2024
Pages 22-40
Critique, Analysis and Aesthetics of Texts

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Hossein Sharifara 1
Garineh Keshishyan Siraki 2

1 PhD in Political Science, Political Thought, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Department of Political Science and International Relations, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran (Corresponding Author)

Abstract
Criticism and its types have been referred to as judgment, evaluation, identification, analysis, review, interpretation, and the like, all of which regard criticism as an interrogative encounter with produced text aiming to explore and examine it. This is while the purpose of this article is to emancipate criticism from the common posterior definitions and as the result to create a fundamental understanding based on text criticism as a priori act in the production process. For this purpose, this article focuses on pre-linguistic and meta-linguistic elements in terms of a non-structural approach and a context for actual production of text as possible conditions. These are meta-historical data which contain the whyness and howness of text formation. Possible conditions are objective and meta-linguistic preconditions. They are different from explanation and interpretation as the realm of mind. Possible conditions are at the heart of historical theory (Historik) and are in relation with long-term processes, playing role in text from the beginning of its formation. Observing possible conditions, as meta-textual conditions make the text actual. It is while criticism, as a possible condition in the creation of text and as a priori and beyond the linguistic narration and hermeneutic features, protects and supports it against any kind of posterior review and judgment. This article attempted to look at the criticism from a different perspective. This led to the extraction of results different from the common ones and to the context required for the actual production of the text event.

Keywords

Criticism
Possible conditions
Text understanding
Text production
Pre givens
Subjects
منابع
آزادی، علیرضا (1394)، «نگاه انتقادی گادامر به هوسرل»، پژوهش­های فلسفی، سال /۹ شماره /16. ص.23.
اسکینر، کوئنتین (1393)، بینش‎های علم سیاست، ترجمه فریبرز مجیدی، تهران، فرهنگ جاوید، 10.
علوی‎پور، سیدمحسن (1396)، «نقد دریدا بر روایت­های «دوستی» در تاریخ اندیشه سیاسی»، تهران، رهیافت­های سیاسی و بین‎المللی، 149.
علی اکبرزاده، حامد ( 1396 )، «بررسی و نقد رویکرد تاریخی­نگری به سنت اسلامی در آرای محمد عابد الجابری و محمد ارکون»، تهران، فصلنامه علمی ـ پژوهشی حکمت اسلامی، سال چهارم، شماره سوم.
فدائی، غلامرضا (1396)، «نقد معیار و معیار نقد، پژوهشنامة انتقادی متون و برنامه‎های علوم انسانی»، تهران، پژوهشگاه علوم انسانی و مطالعات فرهنگی، سال هفدهم، شمارة هفتم.142-127
کارول، نوئل (1392)، درباره نقد، تهران، انتشارات نی.
 
Anker, Elizabeth S. & Felski, Rita editors (2017), Critique and Post critique, Duke University Press.
Baktir, Hassan (2018), Meaning in the Text: Reader-response Theory of Criticism- Meaning in the Text: Reader-response Theory of Criticism, ResearchGate. 
Barthes, Roland (2007), Criticism and Truth, Athlone Press.
Borg, Kurt (2015), Conducting Critique: Reconsidering Foucault’s Engagement with the Question of the Subject, Symposia Melitensia Number 11, CORE.
Butler, Judith (2002), what is Critique? An Essay on Foucault’s Virtue, David Ingram, ed., London: Basil Blackwell UC Berkeley P1.
Devira, Merina & Westin, Elise (2021), A Genre and Appraisal Analysis of Critical Review Texts in Academic Writing from a Systemic Functional Linguistic Perspective, Journal of Research in Applied Linguistics.
Franzel, Sean and Ludwig Hoffmann, Stefan (2018), sediments of time-on possible histories, Stanford University Press Stanford, California.
Lako, Christian (2015), SEMASIOLOGY AND ONOMASIOLOGY IN WEB CONTENT LOCALIZATION, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/293653722.
Learmonth, M. (2004), Derrida reappraised: deconstruction, critique and emancipation in management studies, Working Paper, Department of Management Studies, University of York.
Rao, V. Chandra Sekhar (2020), A Brief Study of Criticism, Hyderabad, India, ISSN: 2456-8104 JRSP-ELT, Issue 17, Vol. 4.
 
 
  • Receive Date 20 March 2024
  • Revise Date 21 April 2024
  • Accept Date 18 May 2024

Home

Submit Manuscript

Reviewers

Contact Us